Young Father Holds Up Two-year Old daughter as she touches an edison light bulb decoratively arranged in a back yard at dusk

Divorcing parents often find themselves thinking about parenting plan terms that they may not fully understand. For instance, the “right of first refusal” is a legal-sounding term that can bring up several questions. Is it required by law? Is it right for my family? Do I even want to include this provision in the parenting plan?

The right of first refusal in a Colorado parenting plan requires parents to give each other the first opportunity to watch the children when the other can’t during their regularly scheduled parenting time. This isn’t an automatic or standard parenting plan term, so parents need to prepare to consider inclusion carefully and negotiate the terms.

Key Takeaways

  • Colorado statutes don’t specifically require a right of first refusal, instead depending on a general child best interest standard.
  • If the parenting plan is silent, parents don’t have an obligation to offer first right of refusal to the other parent.
  • There’s no statutory template, so terms are at parental or court discretion.

What a Right of First Refusal in a Colorado Parenting Plan Requires

So how does this parenting plan term actually work in real life? Typically, parents will include a threshold of time for when the obligation is triggered. This is the amount of time the parent will be away from the child during their parenting time. There’s also typically a notice requirement that defines the method and timing of how to communicate with the other parent. The other parent will have a window of time to respond to the offering parent. Once that window of time closes, the offering parent can move on to alternative childcare options.

It’s common for parents to build in exceptions for the following to help make the right of first refusal more flexible for real-life situations:

  • Routine work-related childcare needs
  • Brief errands
  • Regularly scheduled time with grandparents
  • Absences below the agreed threshold

Because there aren’t any defined statutory requirements, parents are free to negotiate these terms. It’s important for parents to be detailed, as vague or unclear terms can lead to disputes later.

Does Colorado Law Require a Right of First Refusal?

Parents must adhere to Colorado’s statutes that define what may be included in their parenting plan. The statute, C.R.S. 14-10-124(7), specifically addresses several topics, including decision-making, the parenting time schedule, exchange procedures, and communication procedures. It doesn’t specifically address the right of first refusal. However, there’s a catch-all that it can fall under: Colorado prioritizes the best interest of the child, so the right of first refusal would fall under this part of the statute.

With the statute written in this way, parents aren’t required to include a right of first refusal in a Colorado parenting plan. They don’t have to address it at all. That can leave the parenting plan silent on the matter. When that happens, each parent isn’t required to give the other parent any right of first refusal courtesy. There is no fallback law that they must follow. Each parent arranges their own child care as they see fit during their parenting time.

When a Right of First Refusal Helps, and When It Creates Conflict

There’s no universal answer as to whether including a right of first refusal in a Colorado parenting plan is a good idea or not. It’s important for parents to consider their individual situation and their child’s needs. For some parents, having a right of first refusal can maximize both parents’ actual time with their child. It also supports Colorado’s general position of encouraging parents to have frequent and continuing contact with their children.

In some situations, including the right of first refusal can create a rigid standard that sets contentious co-parents up for increased conflict. It sets the stage for minor or routine absences to turn into large battles. This term can be difficult for parents to enforce consistently. Then, some families have varying or unpredictable schedules that make right of first refusal impractical to implement.

Parents should consider their family’s dynamics and communication patterns when considering a right of first refusal.

How a Real Right of First Refusal Dispute Played Out in Colorado

While a right of first refusal in a Colorado parenting plan sounds straightforward when you’re creating the agreement, real-world circumstances can raise new legal questions. An example of this is when the court ruled on In re Marriage of DePalma. The parent’s original parenting plan included a right of first refusal clause. However, the father eventually married. When he was preparing for military deployment, he wanted his new wife to care for his children during his parenting time. He wanted to choose this option over offering his ex-wife and the children’s mother that time.

The Colorado Court of Appeals considered whether the father could arrange for his wife to care for the children during his parenting time without granting her parental rights. The court upheld the arrangement, explaining that the stepmother was not being granted independent parenting time or parental responsibilities. The court also addressed the existing right-of-first-refusal provision. Evidence showed that the parents had not consistently followed the provision and had effectively modified their parenting arrangements through their conduct. Under C.R.S. § 14-10-129, the appellate court concluded that, to the extent the trial court's decision modified the parenting plan, the modification was within its discretion and supported by the children's best interests, including maintaining their established routines and relationships.

The lesson to take from this case is that even when a right of first refusal term is included in the parenting plan, it isn’t absolute. A court may modify how that term is applied in the conflict situation.

Consult with a Colorado Family Law Attorney About Your Parenting Plan

Parents should consider whether a right of first refusal provision would benefit them in their parenting plan. While it isn’t right for all families, it can be beneficial for some. Working with a family law attorney can assist parents in establishing the details beyond a generic template. Altitude Family Law regularly works with Colorado families to help them draft parenting plans that meet their unique child custody needs. Schedule an initial consultation online or call 720-255-1727 to talk about your legal options.